A recent federal court ruling has major implications for how the IRS enforces the Affordable Care Act (ACA)’s Employer Shared Responsibility Provisions (ESRP). Employers who have been assessed ESRP penalties under the ACA may want to take a closer look.
The ruling found that the IRS exceeded its authority by assessing ESRP penalties based on certifications that should have come directly from HHS and not from the IRS. The ACA does not permit HHS to transfer the authority to issue these certifications to the IRS.
The court also said that HHS’s past attempts at issuing these certifications were inadequate. As a result, the IRS’s Letter 226-J, which typically serves as a notice to employers of an ESRP penalty liability, was found to be unsupported in this case. The court ordered a refund of over $205,000 in ESRP penalties to the employer, though it denied a request for attorney’s fees.
If your health plan has been assessed an ESRP penalty without proper certification from HHS, this decision may be relevant to you. If so, please discuss with your legal counsel.
HHS has until late June to appeal this decision. We will keep you posted on any future developments.
Related Blogs
Your Health Plan is Now a Fiduciary Target. Here’s what That Means For Employers
Most employers don’t wake up in the morning thinking about fiduciary liability. If they’re focused on employee benefits, it’s usually on controlling costs, improving ...
Read More
More Usage, Lower Costs: Rethinking Pharmacy Strategy
For most employers, pharmacy feels like a simple equation: more prescriptions = more cost. Utilization goes up, spend follows. That’s been the assumption for ...
Read More
Compensation Planning for 2027
Temperatures are dropping, Halloween decorations are already out, and you know what that means: It’s time for most organizations to finalize salary increase budgets ...
Read More
High-Cost Claims: Why a Small Number of Members Drive Most Healthcare Costs
Healthcare costs often feel unpredictable—but when you break down the data, a clear pattern emerges. Across nearly every employer population, a very small percentage ...
Read More
Why Group Captive Insurance Is Helping Employers Control Rising Healthcare Costs
Rising healthcare costs are forcing employers to rethink how they fund and manage employee benefits. As specialty drug spending, high-cost claims, and medical inflation ...
Read More
The MJ Companies Hires Viridiana Schoenfeld as Employee Benefits Consultant
Leading business and financial services firm expands employee benefits consulting capabilities with strategic hire in Phoenix office PHOENIX (Sept. 14, 2026) – The MJ ...
Read More