more-infomation

P&C Market Update, November 2026 

Looking back on Q3 this year, the usual twists and turns are evident, but so is a generally favorable market. Not that it’s uniformly soft— property and other competitive lines are creating meaningful leverage for buyers just as casualty severity is putting pressure on umbrella and excess programs. 

Here are a few points to note.  

The overall market continues to favor buyers although not uniformly 

Property and several specialty lines are creating meaningful savings opportunities, while casualty continues to experience pressure from loss severity, litigation, and reserve development. The particulars:  

  • U.S. commercial insurance rates declined 1% overall in Q3 2026, following a 2% decrease in Q2.  
  • Property continues to drive the favorable environment, with rates declining 10% amid expanding capacity, strong insurer competition and favorable reinsurance conditions.  
  • Casualty is moving in the opposite direction, with U.S. rates increasing 6%, while financial and professional lines increased 1%.  
  • Cyber rates were flat after an extended period of decreases.  

What this means for insureds: 

For many businesses, total insurance costs may be relatively stable or even decline, but that headline number can mask very different conditions by coverage. Look beyond the total premium change and evaluate each line individually. Property savings, increased capacity, and improved terms may create an opportunity to strengthen coverage, reduce deductibles, or redirect savings toward areas where risk and pricing are increasing. 

Umbrella and excess casualty remain challenging  

Umbrella and excess casualty continue to face significant pricing and capacity pressure as insurers respond to higher claim severity, social inflation, and increasingly large jury awards. 

The litigation environment helps explain the concern. In 2025, nuclear verdicts touched 68 industries and 28 states, and there were nearly 200 corporate jury verdicts of $10 million or more, a 40.7% increase from 2024, representing more than $25.6 billion in total awards. More than 40 verdicts exceeded $100 million, and four exceeded $1 billion.  

What this means for insureds: 

Organizations with significant auto fleets, product liability exposures, large employee populations, or operations in difficult legal jurisdictions should expect greater scrutiny. Underwriters will increasingly focus on loss controls, fleet safety and telematics, contractual risk transfer, claims management, and the quality of the underwriting submission. Businesses should also reassess whether existing umbrella limits remain adequate given the increasing frequency of eight- and nine-figure judgments. 

Building an umbrella tower is becoming more complicated 

Casualty insurers are becoming more selective about where and how much capacity they deploy. U.S.-exposed risks are seeing increased underwriting scrutiny, higher attachment points, and smaller line sizes. Which means the challenge for insureds goes beyond price.  

They may need to use more carriers and more layers to build the same amount of excess protection. Commercial auto is particularly loss-sensitive as casualty insurers remain concerned about social inflation, adverse reserve development, and litigation volatility.  

Recent carrier results reinforce those concerns. Everest reported approximately $600 million of additional gross casualty reserve strengthening in Q3 2026, on top of $200 million in Q2, reflecting continued concern about the ultimate cost of prior-year casualty claims.  

What this means for insureds: 

More carriers and layers can create added complexity at renewal. Insureds should begin casualty marketing early and pay close attention to: 

  • Attachment points and required underlying limits 
  • Consistency of coverage terms across excess layers 
  • Follow-form provisions and exclusions 
  • Carrier financial strength and long-term commitment 
  • Adequacy of total umbrella/excess limits 
  • Potential gaps as multiple carriers participate in the tower 

For larger or more complex programs, structure may be just as important as price. Saving premium on one layer has limited value if it creates a material coverage gap elsewhere in the tower. 

Despite casualty pressure, this remains a strong market for buyers 

The larger commercial insurance market continues to provide considerable opportunity. Q3 represented the ninth consecutive quarter of global commercial rate decreases, supported by strong insurer profitability, excess capital, lower reinsurance costs, and continued competition.  

Property provides the clearest opportunity—A recent report shows that U.S. property rates declined 10% in Q3 and that buyers were able to secure not only lower pricing, but also higher limits, deductible improvements, and broader terms.  

We also recommend insureds use improving market conditions to evaluate program structure, retentions, limits, and coverage, rather than focusing exclusively on premium reduction.  

What this means for insureds: 

This may be the right time to reinvest savings rather than banking them. Property savings can potentially be used to: 

  • Purchase additional umbrella or excess liability limits 
  • Reduce deductibles or retentions 
  • Restore coverage that was restricted during the hard market 
  • Increase limits where asset values or loss severity have grown 
  • Invest in property protection, fleet safety, cybersecurity or other risk controls 
  • Evaluate alternative structures, including captives and other risk-financing strategies 

The bottom line 

The best renewal strategy is not to pursue the lowest possible overall premium but to use today’s favorable market conditions to optimize your entire insurance program, capturing savings where competition is strongest and strategically reinvesting those dollars where loss severity and coverage needs are increasing. 

That approach can leave an insured with a stronger overall program without necessarily increasing total risk spend, which is a much more meaningful measure of renewal success than rate alone.


Risk doesn’t stand still.

Receive quarterly risk management insights designed to help your organization stay ahead.